| Barrage, Rückspiele | 16. November 2015 |
| 93' | Dzeko | |
| 93' | Djuric | |
Whelan O'Shea | 91' | |
| 80' | Lulic Ibisevic | |
Walters (2:0) | 70' | |
| 69' | Medunjanin Djuric | |
McClean | 59' | |
Murphy Long | 55' | |
Hoolahan McClean | 54' | |
| 46' | Cocalic Bešic | |
Walters (1:0) (Penalty) | 24' | |
| 23' | Lulic | |
| 20' | Spahic |